Some parents choose to keep their baby in a bassinet during those first few weeks of life, but both a crib and crib mattress are still necessary for when your infant is ready to transition into their own room or a bigger sleep space. Plus, most mattresses these days grow with baby—making them essential for those newborn days and into toddlerhood. From breathable to washable and organic crib mattresses, there are some great options out there that will keep your baby both comfortable and safe. Newton has a highly-rated mattress that babies can breathe right through, while other brands like Avocado offer a mattress crafted with certified organic cotton, wool and latex so you can trust that it’s safe and non-toxic. Depending on your wants and needs, below are the best-rated crib mattress for your baby—infant and beyond.
The 15 Best Crib Mattresses
1. Newton Original Crib Mattress, $299.99 at Newton Baby
The Newton original crib mattress is a favorite among parents. It is 100% breathable and washable, 5.5 inches thick and features a soft, quilted removable cover. Safe, comfortable and GREENGUARD Gold Certified, it’s a best-seller. Newton Original Crib Mattress, $299.99 at Newton Baby
2. Bedgear’s Air-X Performance Crib and Toddler Mattress, $299.97 at P.C. Richard & Son
Engineered for optimal airflow and chemical free, the Air-X Performance Crib and Toddler Mattress provides a safe, comfortable, and clean sleeping environment. Designed for “two stages,” the mattress has one side with a firm surface for babies 0-12 months old and a softer, adaptive side for toddlers 12 months old and up. The cool-to-touch cover is also washable and waterproof! Bedgear’s Air-X Performance Crib and Toddler Mattress, $299.97 at P.C. Richard & Son
4. Naturepedic Organic Ultra Light Two-Stage Crib Mattress, $299 on Pottery Barn Kids
The GREENGUARD Gold Certified Naturepedic Organic mattress features organic cotton fabric and filling that provides a pure, natural, and comfortable sleep space for babies and toddlers. And the cover is waterproof and boasts a supportive and snug fit for any bed. Naturepedic Organic Ultra Light Two-Stage Crib Mattress, $299 on Pottery Barn Kids
5. Organic Crib Mattress, $439 on Avocado Mattress
Handmade in Los Angeles, Avocado’s Organic Crib Mattress is safe and non-toxic—crafted with certified organic cotton, wool and latex. With a dual-sided design—one for infants and one for toddlers—the mattress offers different firmness levels to support a growing child for years. Organic Crib Mattress, $439 on Avocado Mattress
7. Lullaby Crib Mattress, $199 at West Elm Kids
The Lullaby Crib Mattress is another solid two-stage option – which has different color schemes for the infant side and toddler side. It is both GREENGUARD and CertiPUR-US certified and a waterproof surface makes it easy to keep clean. The mattress edge also has a square corner design for a secure fit inside all convertible cribs. Lullaby Crib Mattress, $199 at West Elm Kids
8. Babyletto Pure Core Two-Stage Crib & Toddler Mattress, $189.99 at BuyBuyBaby
The Babyletto Pure Core Crib Mattress is bundled with a dry waterproof cover, both of which contain the purest ingredients for safe sleep. It’s two-sided (soft and firm), lightweight, hypoallergenic, and GREENGUARD GOLD CERTIFIED. Babyletto Pure Core Two-Stage Crib & Toddler Mattress, $199.99 at BuyBuyBaby
10. Sealy Waterproof Standard Crib Mattress, $70 at Wayfair
The Sealy Waterproof hypoallergenic mattress is extra firm and provides a comfortable sleep for baby. It is compatible with all standard cribs, has a waterproof cover, is antimicrobial and odor resistant. Plus, the eco-friendly design causes less harm to the environment. Sealy Waterproof Standard Crib Mattress, $70 at Wayfair
11. Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Crib Mattress, $199.99 at BuyBuyBaby
The Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer is a dual firmness foam mattress that offers great protection and comfort for your baby (to infant to toddler). It’s hypoallergenic, waterproof and GREENGUARD Gold Certified with CertiPUR-US certified foam. Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Crib Mattress, $199.99 at BuyBuyBaby
13. Organic Dream Cool-Gel Mini Two-Stage Crib Mattress, $149.99 at BuyBuyBaby
Another mini option is the Organic Dream Cool-Gel Mini, which is a two-stage mattress, as well. Crafted with a breathable pure air design and moisture-wicking properties for maximum cooling and temperature regulation, this mattress allows your little one to rest without overheating. It also comes with a water-resistant Organic Cotton cover, that wipes clean and is 100% hypoallergenic. Organic Dream Cool-Gel Mini Two-Stage Crib Mattress, $149.99 at BuyBuyBaby
15. Oeuf White Dual Firm Crib Mattress, $260 at Parachute Home
This Parachute Home non-toxic crib mattress, made by Brooklyn-based children’s lifestyle company Oeuf, also features a firm side for infants and a softer side for toddlers. It is lightweight and durable, and crafted from renewable plant-based foam and white cotton. Oeuf White Dual Firm Crib Mattress, $260 at Parachute Home Next up, 60+ baby freebies, discounts and deals!
